Article Science Technology

Differences make a difference: from one cell to a world of individuality

In our last article, we explored how low-level exposure to antibiotics in the environment is affecting the emergence of resistance genes in Salmonella. Here, we explore how single-cell genomics can elevate our understanding of how AMR arises - and equip us with the knowledge to tackle this existential threat.

30 March 2023

The cell is the functional unit of life on Earth. These remarkable building blocks are equally as successful living solitary lives as when they team up to form multicellular organisms.

In the early days of DNA sequencing, cells from the same species or tissue type were largely thought to be identical. The genetic machinery, it was also believed, would have no reason to deviate from a uniform set of instructions.

But, as technological advances have allowed us to look closer, we’ve been able to observe some glaring differences. 

Recent work applying single-cell genomics to bacteria has been highlighting the incredible extent of microbial diversity – different genomes, different gene expression and differnent mutations that  identify sub-populations within homogeneous populations.

This is particularly apparent when studying the emergence of antimicrobial resistance (AMR). 

The research provided the team with the technical challenge of translating their methods to the study of microbial systems.
Digital graphic of rod-shaped bacteria on a surface

Dr Iain Macaulay is Technical Development Group Leader at the Earlham Institute. He worked closely with collaborators from the Institute and the nearby Quadram Institute to undertake an experiment that used single-cell genomics to see how populations of Salmonella adapted when challenged by weak levels of antibiotics.

Studies exposing bacteria to antibiotics are a common tool for researchers working on AMR. But, in this study, the team’s cutting-edge single-cell genome analysis methods gave a more detailed picture of exactly how resistance genes were evolving.

As expected, there were higher levels of resistance in the population exposed to weak antibiotic treatment. But the novel analysis was able to explore evolution at a single cell level.

This revealed pockets of individuals within this population where overall genetic diversity was developing more quickly, increasing their ability to evade treatment.

“Studying single cells offers a unique perspective to explore almost any biological system” says Dr Macaulay. In fact, he believes this approach is one of the most important lines of enquiry for all future genomics research.

“Everything we really want to understand happens in a single cell,” he explains. “There is so much happening within each cell that can impact the whole population - whether it is a community of bacteria, or a developing organism.

“For example, the dynamics of how cells acquire mutations. Is it random or programmed? What order do mutations happen in? Do they exclude each other – if a specific mutation happens in one place, does that mean another can’t happen in a different place? And once they have happened, what impact do those mutations have on the overall viability of the organism?”

The majority of single-cell sequencing approaches so far have been designed for eukaryotic, rather than prokaryotic, cells. We’d used these approaches to study cells in the human body involved in ageing or cancer, but not to analyse bacteria or the microbiome.

Invisible details

Microbes have been typically analysed either by characterising individual microorganisms one by one – a time- and labour-intensive practice with little idea about how representative the cell is – or by bulk sequencing of cultured samples, which gives a representative average of the genetic changes occurring in populations but misses detail at the individual level.

The higher-resolution data generated by this technology is revealing previously invisible details.

Dr Macaulay says: “The majority of single cell sequencing approaches so far have been designed for eukaryotic, rather than prokaryotic, cells. We’d used these approaches to study cells in the human body involved in ageing or cancer, but not to analyse bacteria or the microbiome.”

He says the opportunity to translate these methods to microbial systems was a fascinating technical challenge.

“It was a very interesting question,” says Macaulay. “Could we apply the same single-cell sequencing techniques to bacteria that we’d previously used with mammalian cells?

“We weren’t even sure it would be possible - or whether the techniques we’d previously been using would need adapting. But, in fact, we used exactly the same methods and found it worked very well.”

Salmonella is already well characterised, which meant Dr Macaulay and his team had a clear reference genome to map the DNA of the single cells.

“Because we had this good genome coverage we were able to go deeper with the analysis, looking at variation at individual bases within the genome” he explains.

“It started as a proof-of-principle study - something we really weren’t sure would work - but very quickly became really promising. This is just the start – we are continuing to develop our single-microbial work, looking for new tools and applications which could help AMR research.

“A high-throughput system specifically for analysing microbial systems has a number of wide-ranging possibilities for the future.”

It started as a proof-of-principle study - something we really weren’t sure would work - but very quickly became really promising. This is just the start – we are continuing to develop our single-microbial work, looking for new tools and applications which could help AMR research.

A powerful tool

Single-cell sequencing technology provides an unprecedented level of cell-specific genetic information. It has the potential to revolutionise several areas of genetics, including classifying microbes, documenting evolution, and analysing drug resistance.

The approach developed by Dr Johana Hernandez in Dr. Macaulay’s lab used fluorescence-activated cell sorting, followed by multiple displacement amplification, to isolate and sequence genomes from hundreds of individual bacterial cells. Dr Matt Bawn then undertook comprehensive bioinformatic analysis of the individual genomes, weeding out any errors to generate a true picture of the evolutionary events happening in the culture. 

This approach could also be used on uncultured cells, which means it offers the tantalising possibility of sequencing microbes we are not yet able to successfully grow in labs.

Researchers have only studied a very small fraction of the vast number of microbial species in the world. Part of this is sheer diversity, but another major hurdle is the difficulty of culturing in a laboratory setting. 
The majority of microorganisms require environmental conditions that are so specific the cost and logistics mean they cannot currently be grown in laboratories.

Complex microbial ecosystems are all - at their roots - made up of diverse, individual cells. 

Understanding this diversity - both within and between populations - will transform our knowledge of bacterial disease and may be key to stemming the rise of antimicrobial resistance.


 

In our next feature, we will be discussing the possible future of single-cell sequencing with Yash Bancil and Karim Gharbi. You can read the first in our AMR series below.

Image
Profile of Amy Lyall
Article author

Amy Lyall

Scientific Communications and Outreach Officer